• Why Plant-Based?
    • Overview
    • Sustainability
    • Better health
    • Compassion for animals
  • Resources
    • Virtual speaker series
    • Speakers program
    • Pamphlets
    • Newsletters
  • Blog
  • About Us
    • Who we are
    • Contact us
  • How to Help
    • Join us
    • Donate
  • Subscribe to Newsletter
Earthsave CanadaEarthsave Canada
  • Why Plant-Based?
    • Overview
    • Sustainability
    • Better health
    • Compassion for animals
  • Resources
    • Virtual speaker series
    • Speakers program
    • Pamphlets
    • Newsletters
  • Blog
  • About Us
    • Who we are
    • Contact us
  • How to Help
    • Join us
    • Donate
  • Subscribe to Newsletter

No, Bill C-293 on pandemic prevention is not the “Vegan Act”

No, Bill C-293 on pandemic prevention is not the “Vegan Act”

No, Bill C-293 on pandemic prevention is not the “Vegan Act”

March 4, 2025 Posted by David Steele

By Renaud Gignac, LL.B., M.Sc., President of Transition AlimenTerre Québec, and David Steele, PhD, President of Earthsave Canada.

A version of this article was published in La Presse (Montreal) on February 2, 2025. It can be read (in French) here.


In his January 9 article, Ottawa chaos saved farmers and consumers, Professor Sylvain Charlebois claims that the prorogation of the federal Parliament was a blessing, having suspended consideration of bills he claims are harmful to both farmers and consumers.

Charlebois is delighted that capital gains reform will not now happen. According to him, the reform “would have represented a significant financial burden” on farmers. However, he completely ignores the measures included in the bill in order to protect farmers, including an increase in the capital gains exemption for farm property from $1 million to $1,250,000.

Most surprising, though, is his claim that Bill C-293, a bill designed to prevent pandemics, is instead a “Vegan Act”. Charlebois claims that Bill C-293  “appears to impose a particular dietary program – in this case, vegetarian and vegan – under the guise of public health” and “includes provisions to promote the consumption of alternative proteins.”

His claim is simply not true. No matter how hard one looks, one cannot find where in the bill Professor Charlebois could find the evidence to come to such a conclusion.

The bill mandates the development of plans by the Ministry of Health, in coordination with Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada and the Ministry of Industry, to both reduce pandemic risk and to facilitate rapid responses to any such threats that may arise.  

Measures are prescribed to ensure that health care workers are better prepared to respond to sudden increases in patient volume and that planning be done to ensure the supply chains of personal protective equipment, vaccines, etc., are as protected and secure as possible.

So, too, are preparedness strategies for the protection of the most vulnerable groups and to bolster the surge capacity of our institutions to deal with the stresses and needs that a new pandemic would impose.

It is true that, among the actions mandated by the bill, are the regulation of animal agriculture so as to lower the probability of antibiotic resistance arising among farm animals and to make the likelihood of new virus variants arising on Canadian farms less likely.

Both are eminently rational goals. Note, for example, the current threats that farmers face with bird flu – and the likely human to human transmission of a variant of that flu recently identified in the United States. That said, no specific actions are mandated; these would be formulated by the various ministries based on their own judgment of the risks at hand.

Yes, the bill would make it easier for government to halt production in meat processing facilities in the case of a pandemic, and to regulate the conditions under which animals are raised where those conditions pose a serious threat to the public health. Slaughterhouse workers were among the most likely of all people to be infected in the Covid-19 pandemic, so the ability to regulate or close them more easily in the event of another pandemic is plain and simply prudent.

The bill puts not a single constraint on the consumption of meat or other animal products.

Where exactly in the text of Bill C-293 did Charlebois read that it would “mandate the consumption of vegetable proteins by Canadians” or “legislate the consumption of vegetable proteins”? These claims are simply not true.

Bill C-293 does not even mention consumption. In that regard, it requires only that Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada provide measures to “promote commercial activities that can help reduce pandemic risk, including the production of alternative proteins”. Once again, a prudent action and one that would boost our ability to compete in a rapidly growing global market.

Bill C-293 is a rational response to a serious threat. It aims to reduce the likelihood of pandemics arising within our borders and to bolster our responses to any pandemics that may nevertheless arise here or arrive on our shores. 

Promoting the production of plant proteins in Canada, without any constraints on consumption, is not only part of a very rational and important risk-reduction trajectory, but would also strengthen the competitiveness of our farmers in a rapidly expanding global market.

Unfortunately, the prorogation of Parliament will not make the risks of future pandemics disappear at the same time as Bill C-293. We’ll have to stay on our toes if we want to avoid finding ourselves again in the same bad movie.

About Renaud Gignac

Renaud is a climate policy expert with a background as an economist and a lawyer. He held various positions at the Quebec Ministry of Environment and Climate Change, the Canadian Climate Institute, in the private and nonprofit sectors, and in academia. He is a co-founder of the Coalition for a Sustainable Food Transition.

Share
Avatar photo

About David Steele

David is a molecular biologist retired in 2013 from the Faculty of Medicine at the University of British Columbia. He has also held faculty positions at Cornell and Queen’s Universities. Dr. Steele is a frequent public speaker and a regular contributor to Earthsave Canada's publications. He is also an occasional contributor to various other publications.

You also might be interested in

The problem with palm oil

May 2, 2016

By David Steele, President of Earthsave Canada Insidiously it creeps,[...]

COP 30: The impacts of animal agriculture on the climate

COP 30: The impacts of animal agriculture on the climate

Aug 21, 2025

The 30th climate edition of COP, happening in Brazil this November, will be an opportunity to address the outsized impact of animal agriculture on the climate crisis. The host country should lead by example - and so should Canada.

Only cooperation can save us

Only cooperation can save us

May 17, 2016

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) hit us with[...]

Recent Posts

  • Scientists Across the World are Taking Major Personal Actions to Combat Global Warming
  • A Critical Look at the WRI’s Recent GHG Source Assessment
  • Beyond the protein myths: why plant-based protein deserves a place on your plate
  • A Tale of Two Santa Martas

Follow us

If you found this helpful please consider donating.

Donate

Engage with us on facebook

Earthsave Canada

Earthsave Canada

1 day 2 hours ago

"All social animals face a familiar problem: they need to reach agreements. For example, female buffalo indicate with their heads the direction they want to

2
View on Facebook
Share

Earthsave Canada

1 day 4 hours ago

"Published in Advances in Nutrition, the International Food Guide Pyramid synthesizes evidence from more than 250 scientific publications and dietary guidelines from seven countries and

New International Food Pyramid Highlights Plant Foods, Counters Trump’s Meat-Heavy Diet Advice

The new dietary advice encourages plant-based proteins such as beans, lentils, nuts and soy, without excluding fish, poultry, eggs or dairy. The guide can also be adapted for vegetarian and vegan diets. , Nutrition News, Health and Me

2
View on Facebook
Share

Earthsave Canada

1 day 7 hours ago

"With cattle in feedlots receiving a range of pharmaceuticals, like hormones and antibiotics, an illness or death could be linked to more than one treatment.

Lame, Suffocated and Dead: The Drug Supersizing America’s Cattle

The investigation reveals troubling safety findings, reports of cattle deaths and questions about industry influence on the FDA and research universities.

2
View on Facebook
Share

© 2026 · Earthsave Canada.